Reconnecting with nature to reboot our “spiritual self” activates a feeling of self-transcendence
Video: Buddhist Teachings on Ngondro, The Foundation Practices with Venerable Zasep Rinpoche
Kucchivikara-vattha: The Monk with Dysentery (Sutra teachings) “If you don’t tend to one another, who then will tend to you?”
“Putting Compassion on the Scientific Map”: Compassion Boosts Happiness/Health; and Research Indicates That Practicing Buddhists Are Happier than Average.
Video with wonderful mantra chanting: Om Gate Gate Paragate Para Samgate Bodhi Soha, the essence of Heart Sutra and Emptiness
Music Mantra Video: Taking Refuge in Buddha, Dharma and Sangha and the Four Immeasurables wonderfully sung by Yoko Dharma with video visualizations
Broken Commitments: 3 Teachers weigh in on practice “overload” and breaking Vajrayana practice promises. What do we do about it?
Dalai Lama and Lama Tsongkhapa: teachings on calm abiding meditation that go beyond “the breath” as the focus — targeting the main affliction
Music Mantra Video: Om Mani Padme Hum wonderfully chanted by Yoko Dharma, the sacred sound of compassionate Buddha Chenrezig
Tara Book excerpt and teaching: Who is Tara and how can She help us? An introduction to Tara, Karma, Shunyata, Dependent Arising, and Buddha Nature by Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche
What’s with all this consort union in Tantric Buddhism? No, it’s not about sexual fantasies. The psychology of Yab-Yum consorts, union of wisdom and compassion
Video: “How do I deal with my anger? Sometimes it consumes me and hurts others”: a Buddhist student asks teacher Ven. Zasep Tulku Rinpoche
Video: “Experience Buddhism” with Namdrol Rinpoche “Buddhism emphasizes, and lays its very foundations on, equanimity.”
Lama Zopa Rinpoche and other teachers recommend Kṣitigarbha mantra and practice for times of disaster, especially hurricane and earthquake, because of the great Bodhisattva’s vow
Medicine Buddha healing mantras chanted by the amazing Yoko Dharma
Why 35 Confessional Buddhas practice and “The Bodhisattva’s Confession of Moral Downfalls” is a critical purifying practice for Buddhists
What the Dalai Lama and Patch Adams Have in Common: Laughter, and Compassion, the Best Medicine
“Preliminary practices… clear and enrich our minds, allowing practice to progress smoothly” — Thubten Chodron. Why Ngondro is a lifetime practice, and a “complete path”
Tantra Helps “Stop Ordinary Perception”, and is the Fast Path to Enlightenment. But How Do Modern Buddhists Relate to Deities?
Painter and digital Thangka artist Jampay Dorje aims to bring “Thangka painting into a modern era” with spectacular art, lessons for students, and a life-long project to illustrate all of the 11 Yogas of Naropa
Buddha teaches us to view every meal as if we were reluctant cannibals: Samyukta Agama Sutra 373, the Four Nutriments
Letting Go — letting go of past, letting go of future, letting go is the hardest thing to do: Na Tumhaka Sutta
Becoming Gesar, the fearless Buddhist: How to overcome fear in uncertain times, according to Pali Sutta, Mahayana Sutra and Tantra
The Hand of Buddha defeats the three poisons : Vajrapani (literally, “Vajra Hand”) — Guardian of Shakyamuni Himself; Vajrapani, the power of the mind to overcome obstacles such as pride, anger, hate and jealousy
Tonglen video: Why giving and taking practice is an important kindness meditation and Bodhichitta practice; how to do it: taught by Zasep Rinpoche
Understanding Dependent Co-Arising is critical to Buddhist practice: The Great Causes Discourse Maha-nidana Sutta
Pali Sutta for Our Age: Old Path White Clouds: Walking in the Footsteps of the Buddha by Thich Nhat Hanh, a Book Review of a Classic
The bridge between science and Buddhism, atoms and no atoms, theism and athiesm; Yidam deity meditation and the Cognitive Science of Tantra
“Every one has Buddha Nature.” A teaching video: Venerable Zasep Rinpoche with mantra chanting by Yoko Dharma
Cankama Sutta: Walking Meditation Sutra: put some mileage on your Buddhist practice with formal mindful walking
Milam Sleep Yoga: lucid dreaming can bring us closer to experiencing non-dualistic “reality” than waking meditation
2017 Tsog Dates: Happy Dakini Day — Introducing the Wisdom of the Female Enlightened Dakinis
Guan Yin and the ten great protections of the Goddess of Mercy: Avalokiteshvara, Bodhisattva of Compassion
The Maha Samaya Sutta: The Great Meeting Sutra: refuge from fear in Buddha, Dharma and Sangha
Soma Sutta: Sister Soma gets the better of Mara — what difference does being a woman make in Buddhism? None
Healing video: full Medicine Buddha guided meditation with Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche; with Medicine Buddha Mantra chanting by Yoko Dharma
Rebirth Part 2: Is There Scientific Evidence of Rebirth?

Rebirth Part 2: Is There Scientific Evidence of Rebirth?

The concept of reincarnation and rebirth has successfully captivated human beings over the ages. Although the terms “Reincarnation” and “Rebirth” are often used inter-changeably, there is a significant difference between the two concepts. Reincarnation is normally understood to be the assumption of another body by a permanent self or a “soul”. According to this doctrine, after the biological death, the soul transmigrates into another body. Rebirth, on the other hand, is the idea that it is not a “permanent self” but a form of subtle mind-stream which conjoins with a new life after the death of its previous one. This mind-stream carries within itself karmic imprints from previous births. Also, rebirth doesn’t necessarily have to be in human form, a human being can be reborn as any other sentient being, depending on the karmic cycle.

Reincarnation and rebirth are mainly eastern concepts and form the basic tenets of the three major eastern religions of Hinduism, Jainism and Buddhism. However, Hinduism and Jainism talk mostly about reincarnation of the soul, or Atman, Buddhism focuses on rebirth of consciousness.

Rebirth wheel and reincarnation cycle
Spectacular tankha of the wheel of suffering, illustrating samsara and rebirths in various worlds, a concept bound up not only in Buddhism, Hinduism, Janaism and Taoism—but given credibility (the concept of rebirth) by scientists.

The doctrine of Buddhism discounts the existence of a soul or Atman. According to ancient Buddhist texts, there is no permanent self which moves from one life to another. Instead, it is the consciousness or the stream of consciousness which, upon the end of one life, joins another, much like a flame which is transferred from one candle to another. There is a certain relationship between the past and the present lives, neither are they identical, nor completely distinct.

Such transmigration of consciousness is the effect of Karma, and this process of rebirth continues until the consciousness attains Nirvana, or complete independence of material wants and desires. Only then, can the “self” be free.

What Does Science Say?

Please see Part 1 of Rebirth Series: Is There Scientific Evidence of Rebirth is here>>

In our present world, driven with science and rationality, the opinion is divided about the existence of the phenomenon of reincarnation. However, scientists have routinely been presented with evidence to at least partially support the notion of rebirth. Reincarnation or rebirth serve as the only conceivable explanation for children as young as three years of age, having detailed knowledge of their past lives, where they stayed, what they did, even how they dies. Other evidence of reincarnation includes xenoglossy, or ability to speak in a language with a person has never learnt and existence of matching scars and birthmarks.

What Constitutes Proof of Rebirth?

In science, generally, to refute a theory, you only need one refuting piece of evidence. At least, that’s the standard used when refuting theories. In other words, science cannot unequivocally state there is no rebirth or reincarnation as long as there is one instance of rebirth. Professor Ian Stephenson’s landmark work, widely accepted in the scientific community as valid, presents multiple instances of children with memories of previous lives. To read more about his work, see part one of this series>>

The Body is Reborn Every Second?

In theory, the human body is constantly being reborn. Cells in the body are constantly reborn. Even though we might hold  the illusion that we are unchanging, in fact we are a different physical human being now, than we were one month ago. The same is true of the Universe. Of every atom and molecule in the Universe. We are constantly recycling, even within our “one lifetime.” It is, perhaps, for the more science-oriented, easier to accept the notion of some form or rebirth. It’s easier to accept recycling of energy and matter, certainly, than extinction.

Quantum Theory

The landmark work of Fritjof Capra, The Tao of Phsyics, still best introduces the parallels between modern physics and eastern philosophical thought: “Quantum theory thus reveals a basic oneness of the universe. It shows that we cannot decompose the world into independently existing smallest units. As we penetrate into matter, nature does not show us any isolated “building blocks,” but rather appears as a complicated web of relations between the various parts of the whole. These relations always include the observer in an essential way. The human observer constitute the final link in the chain of observational processes, and the properties of any atomic object can be understood only in terms of the object’s interaction with the observer”

The concepts of basic oneness, “cannot decompose”, and observational processes could interchangeably be used when discussing Quantum Theory or Buddhist Teachings. Mr. Capra wrote: “If physics leads us today to a world view which is essentially mystical, it returns, in a way, to its beginning, 2,500 years ago. … This time, however, it is not only based on intuition, but also on experiments of great precision and sophistication, and on a rigorous and consistent mathematical formalism.”

Nasa Scientist and Physicist Thomas Campbell

Thomas Campbell, and eminent scientist, believes in reincarnation. In a review on a video featuring Dr. Campbell, the site Beyond the Psychic Veil summarized the argument this way:

There is no time. There is no space. Everything is one. Hence, we are all experiencing everything all at once. That means you are you, you are the neighbor, the dog (yes animals may reincarnate as well), the kid on the skateboard, the grouchy guy in the corner store, you are me, the Dalai Lama, Jesus, Hitler, Joan of Arc. You are everyone, all at once, in all points of time, and all points of space. However … you are focused on seeing and experiencing reality through your perspective only at this time.”

This isn’t evidence of rebirth, certainly, but the arguments are a fit with current Quantum theory. If, in fact, it’s a matter of perspective, rebirth becomes an easy notion to accept. The arguments are also very inline with Buddhist concepts of existence, emptiness, and self.


Past Life Regression

Putting aside physics, other types of evidence—albeit not accepted by everyone—is past life regression. Past life regression is a method by which a patient is put in a trance and guided by a series of questions into her past life. This can lead to the answers of many questions in an individual’s present life, for example, someone’s irrational fear of insects could be accounted to a trauma suffered in one’s past life.

Although many scientists have heavily criticized some pieces of evidence which prove the existence of reincarnation, some scientists are skeptical. The events which have occurred have no other rational explanation except reincarnation or rebirth. The field of science is heavily divided on this issue, although nothing in science contradicts the possibility of rebirth, and many scientists argue there is substantial suggestive evidence that rebirth is more than just a mystical concept.

Karmic Wheel or Wheel of Suffering
A universal image in Buddhism is the “wheel of Samsara” which illustrates how clinging, suffering and karma bind us to an unending cycle of rebirth. Shakyamuni Buddha taught the path to Enlightenment, and freedom from the wheel of suffering.

15 Responses to Rebirth Part 2: Is There Scientific Evidence of Rebirth?

  1. You write: “Reincarnation or rebirth serve as the only conceivable explanation for children as young as three years of age, having detailed knowledge of their past lives, where they stayed, what they did, even how they dies. Other evidence of reincarnation includes xenoglossy, or ability to speak in a language with a person has never learnt and existence of matching scars and birthmarks.”

    I feel like you need more argument to say “only conceivable explanation”. Are you aware of other explanations? Could it be coincidence? Who reported the incident? What are the circumstances of someone who alleges someone spoke a language they have never heard? Was there a person present who spoke that language. How would you verify that someone never heard it?

    My point is that to make your case stronger, I suggest you present the other explanations and work them. Just stating that it’s the only conceivable explanation might just be a limitation in yourself, and not the larger world, and in no way to do you begin to prove that in your essay. Seems a short cut. Maybe you could apply your open mindedness to that.

    • Hi Stephen,
      Well said. Part 2 in this series (this article) was written by one of our contributors. A different contributor wrote an in-depth piece on the subject which carried some of those arguments through. Personally, I agree “only conceivable explanation” is too strongly stated. Here’s the link to part one if you missed it:

      In that piece, the contributor made this, along with several other arguments: “The best known evidence is the work of Ian Stevenson, who spent fifteen years collecting data from over 4500 people who spontaneously recalled past lives. According to Dr. Robert Almeder of Georgia State University, “This was important research, empirical research and I could not think of any alternative explanation as plausible for the data as that some people reincarnate.” … he went on to add: “Dr. Stephenson himself said, “It’s not unreasonable to believe, because this is the best fit on the data.” One of the reasons why the data is not refutable is the presentation of supporting historical facts, supporting the spontaneous memories of children 2-4 years old. These children had no exposure to past live history information, yet unfailingly gave details of past lives that were verifiable.

      We plan to invite further contributions on this topic. It’s a conversation worth pursuing. Namaste.

  2. you are all wrong.recently i have discovered the rebirth theory with evidence.and i challange the world scientist to speak to me on the subject.

      • Mr. bakhtiar i must tell u ,rebirth is very occasional,I can tell an event when i was a small kid, but i do remember the instance, there was a little girl ageing may be of approxi 4 yrs heading the huge public along with punjabi band baja, bakhtiar g with ages i even got old but i do remember the instance. I asked my mother about the Jalsa, she replied none of her knowledge.I asked my grand mother , now she is no more, she told me the story.That a girl was murdered.The only answer, she was a girl , the only gunaah was what i come to know ,her gunaah ,was to stand on roof to dry her hair in sunlight, about rebirth i must tell u , she came with her identity, , recognition of name, place , and identity

  3. The theory of animal’s rebirth was the challenging and most wanted question for the scientists in the past. But to day on ward it is no more question. I have defined this theory with great accuracy and evidence. According to my this rebirth theory i shall tell the scientists and the world that a human when dies how he rebirths in shape and life of Buffalo, cow, camel, birds , crocodiles, fish ,snake, lion , horse, dog etc, And when these animals dies rebirths in life of human . There fore i challenge the world scientists to discuss it with me and to inquire me about this discovery. I am intrusted to show this amazing discovery to the world. in Presence of Press and electronic media in Pakistan.

    Bakhtiar Ali
    Email :
    PH : 03005931937


  4. The comment that ‘it is irrational not to believe in rebirth’ needs some qualification. As is set out in this piece it is misrepresented slightly. It basically means: if one were to face it with an open mind it would be irrational to not consider it as a possibility. From that statement it does not follow that it’s true or it is irrational to consider other possibilities. It makes quite a mild statement that since the evidence is there it is irrational to not consider the theory.

  5. The fact is that the outcome of any analysis on the existence or rebirth or not, is beyond our control. We do not have choice on what we have to become in our next life, if at all it exists. The discussion on this thus will have no productive end. The important point worth noting is that there is no repetition of an individual, come what may. We do not see another Einstien,Gandhi or Krishna of the same acumen around us, though we wish they where here again.

    • Thanks, much respect to you and your views. My view, somewhat supported I think in Buddhist teachings, though, is that Karma (actions) do influence how we are reborn (so it’s not entirely true we can’t help control our path of future rebirths). That’s not objectively provable, of course; rebirth on the other hand may someday be objectively demonstrated by science. Some data strongly suggests it already (case data), and also certainly a vast quantity of subjective data. On the idea of the discussion having “no productive end” I respectively disagree. All discussions are productive and it’s not valid to say even light discussions are unproductive. On the assertion “there is “no repetition of an individual” that is not necessarily the case, again in my opinion supported by some case data. We don’t know objectively, but again subjective data suggests that some identification survives (i.e. in a vast quantity of carefully collected past memories from young children in several big studies point to this), so I don’t think that statement can stand either. I don’t think the important point is whether Einstien will be reborn with full memory of self, but only that whatever is reborn continues. In Buddhism, we tend to think of EGO rather than individual (individual is too difficult to define). Ego leads to attachment and suffering, etc, etc, (longer discussion i.e the Four Noble Truths, the Noble Eightfold Path, etc), but ultimately we talk of ego not surviving. Ego is not the same as whatever we define as mind (which is what “survives” according to most beliefs; some say the soul, but Buddhist tend to point to the mind). Just because that selfish part that wants to cling to “I was once Joe Ingles of Florida” doesn’t mean that the essential mind of Joe Ingles didn’t continue as an ego-less mindstream… nothing’s objectively provable, but subjective evidence does support may of the Buddhist (and Hindu) beliefs in rebirth. And a wide body of data also suggests, that the unconscious mind does in fact retain identification from previous lives (i.e. the study of those many children who recall past lives in great detail). Some psychologists theorize that this ego is buried in what Dr. Jung would have called the Shadow (unconcious mind) in the same way a traumatized person might bury memories of their childhood because of abuse… it’s too painful to “recall” so the mind submerges it. This, together with the study data, at least leaves room for robust discussion and keeps it very much a positive one. Just my view, much respect to yours and thank you for commenting!

    • Mother gives birth an empty body of a child and the Surrounding and the time give birth the self /soul and heart of the child . So, like surrounding like mind, like mind like action ,like action like result and the result is what we every one are at now. Be it Einstien , Mahatma Gandhi , Lord Buddha or a renowned terrorist or anybody at present . Everybody’s present state is the result of their mind and action in their respective surrounding and time. So, if someone is given rebirth , he will be what his surrounding and time will determine…….So, in order to have a better life we need to get a better surrounding or a best surrounding . The Surrounding may be anything that influence our sense or feeling in our prenatal state or in our postnatal state or in our infant state or in our childhood……..So, the feeling of ” I ” or the self comes from our surrounding . I am this , I like this , I do not like this . In every moment our surrounding works on us which determine what we are at now….. So there will be no repeating of a character even if we take a rebirth …….

  6. Bogus arguments for and against rebirth or reincarnation. Fact is what we see and experience in our life journey. Science will theorise and religions will foolhardily debate. Those who have seen and experienced will be sure of rebirth and those who have failed will not believe in it. Try to read An odyssey into other realms of thought,a book.

    • Hi and thanks for commenting. It would be nice if you would explain why you believe the arguments are bogus — both ways. I am personally open to all views, but there is nothing in the arguments that is not plausible, and even if you believe there is, please explain why, and cite your references in more detail. One book or one author isn’t a convincing counter-argument. Basically, I’m guessing, but with respect, this sounds like a strong personal opinion — a sort of “oh, what nonsense” reaction to a topic, without breaking down why you feel that way.

      • Further to the above, specifically, the author writes: “In science, generally, to refute a theory, you only need one refuting piece of evidence. At least, that’s the standard used when refuting theories.” Perhaps, that would be the best approach to making the counter argument…. “what is the one piece of refuting evidence?” One reason this topic remains an open one is there is no piece of refuting evidence. In kindness, Derek

Leave a reply

Are you a Sentient Being? *

Awarded Top 50 Buddhist Blog

Copyright Buddha Weekly 2007-2017. All Rights Reserved. Please feel free to excerpt stories with full credit and a link to Budddha Weekly. Please do not use more than an excerpt. Subject to terms of use and privacy statement. All information on this site, including but not limited to, text, graphics, images and other material contained on this website are for informational purposes only. The purpose of this website is to promote  understanding and knowledge. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, including medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.

Buddha Weekly does not recommend or endorse any information that may be mentioned on this website. Reliance on any information appearing on this website is solely at your own risk.

Send this to a friend