Cankama Sutta: Walking Meditation Sutra: put some mileage on your Buddhist practice with formal mindful walking
Milam Sleep Yoga: lucid dreaming can bring us closer to experiencing non-dualistic “reality” than waking meditation
2017 Tsog Dates: Happy Dakini Day — Introducing the Wisdom of the Female Enlightened Dakinis
Guan Yin and the ten great protections of the Goddess of Mercy: Avalokiteshvara, Bodhisattva of Compassion
The Maha Samaya Sutta: The Great Meeting Sutra: refuge from fear in Buddha, Dharma and Sangha
Soma Sutta: Sister Soma gets the better of Mara — what difference does being a woman make in Buddhism? None
Healing video: full Medicine Buddha guided meditation with Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche; with Medicine Buddha Mantra chanting by Yoko Dharma
Phurba or Kila: the most potent of wrathful ritual implements in Vajrayana Buddhism, symbolizes the Karma activity of the Buddhas
Happy Birthday Venerable Zasep Rinpoche: May the pure white light of your peerless wisdom shine undiminished until the end of existence
Buddha: How to protect wealth, associate with virtuous friends and relate to your spouse, employer, children: guidance for lay practitioners in Sigalovada Sutta
“Mind is the creator of our own happiness or suffering”—Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche teaches Lojong  Seven-Point Mind Training
The Path of Purification? No, my friend. Ratha-vinita Sutta (Chariot Relay Sutra) teaches us not to confuse the seven purifications, with the destination, Nirvana
Atisha’s Great Praise: 11th century wisdom.
Why Buddha Nature is one of the most important understandings in Mahayana Buddhism and why Tathagatagarbha Buddha Nature is not the soul
Why do Buddhas and Enlightened Beings need offerings? The simple answer: they don’t. The better answer is…
Book Review: Tara in the Palm of Your Hand: a guide to the practice of the twenty-one Taras in the Surya Gupta lineage
Amitabha Sutra: cutting delusions with one-pointed blissful contemplation of Amitabha Buddha and the Pure Land
Reviving the genuine Dharma ritual art traditions: an interview with Vajra artisan and craftsman Rigdzin Pema Tuthob
Great Compassion Mantra: Purification, healing and protection, the Maha Karuna Dharani Sutra — benefiting all beings
Video: Why is Mantra important to daily practice? For protection: “We are human beings. We have many problems.”
A Sutra for Troubled Times: Usnisa Vijaya Dharani Sutra and Mantra— Purify Karma, Eliminate Illness and Prevent calamities
Naked wisdom for degenerate times: Vajrayogini, enlightened wisdom queen, leads us to bliss, clear light and emptiness, despite modern obstacles
Headed for darkness or light? Of world’s 7.5 billion people, Tamonata Sutta says there are four types of people, two headed to darkness
Interview Lama Dr. Shannon Young: Dzogchen teacher focuses on bringing Dharma practice into daily life and bridging heritage with modern life
H.H. 17th Karmapa Ogyen Trinley Dorje in Canada for one month, arrived in Toronto for teachings
What’s so special about Hayagriva? This wrathful Heruka emanation of Amitabha, with horse head erupting from fiery hair, literally neighs with the Hrih scream of Wisdom
Mahāsatipaṭṭhāna Sutta: The Great Discourse on the Establishing of Awareness; mindfulness of body, feelings, mind, mental qualities
Difficult lesson of karma: even “mass murderer” turned Arhat, Angulimala, had to bear the consequences of 999 murders
Video: Why a teacher-coach is important and how to practice Guru Yoga;  the “inconvenient” subject many teachers avoid
“Mahamudra is ultimately about trying to experience absolute truth” — and Helping Your Mind Get to Know Your Mind: Teaching Retreat Notes, Zasep Tulku Rinpoche
A Better Way to Catch a Snake Sutra: Buddha explains the danger of misinterpreting the Dharma
Happy Wesak Day! On this most sacred day, celebrating the birth, Enlightenment and Paranirvana of Gautama Buddha, we wish all sentient beings health, happiness, and ultimate Enlightenment.
Finding the Good in Any Situation and “Turn the other cheek”? The Sutra with Advice to Venerable Punna from the Buddha
Healing and Foundation Practices Video: Learning from the Teachers Video Series with Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche
Buddha’s Teachings on Anger Management: Five Ways to Put an End to Anger, or to Use it Constructively and 3 Sutras on Anger
Overcoming Fear: Three Remedies for Fear; What Buddha had to Say About Fearlessness in Abhaya Sutta
Veterinarian’s Suicide with Animal Euthanasia Drugs a Protest Against Animal “Mercy” Killings: What Do Buddhist Teachers Say About Animal Euthanasia?

Veterinarian’s Suicide with Animal Euthanasia Drugs a Protest Against Animal “Mercy” Killings: What Do Buddhist Teachers Say About Animal Euthanasia?

Veterinarian Jian Zhicheng (Chien Chih-cheng 簡稚澄) killed herself in protest over the forced “mercy” killings of animals. Her suicide was a shocking act — a distressed plea to stop the killing. She used the same drugs she had been compelled to use on over 700 stray dogs by the system which encouraged euthanasia to avoid over-crowding. When the average stay for a dog or cat dropped to only 12 days — after which they would be automatically killed — Zicheng couldn’t carry on. By some accounts, after she self-administered the “sleep” drug she had used on animals, she suffered for a long time before dying.

 

Vetranarian Jian Zhicheng (Chien Chih-cheng 簡稚澄) killed herself in protest over the forced "mercy" killings of animals. From a TV broadcast where she appealed to the public to adopt more shelter pets.
Vetranarian Jian Zhicheng (Chien Chih-cheng 簡稚澄) killed herself in protest over the forced “mercy” killings of animals. From a TV broadcast where she appealed to the public to adopt more shelter pets.

 

Zicheng’s terrible gesture is not even an isolated incident. Although not confirmed as the reason, another vet — a well known author and pet columnist — also committed suicide in California. The pressure on veterinarians — who went to school to learn how to save lives — will only grow as countries around the world not only approve of — but actively encourage — euthanasia of stray animals.

At Buddha Weekly, most of our contributors are outspoken against euthanasia. Zicheng’s sad death encouraged us to focus on this issue — and ask “What the Buddhist Teacher’s Say” about Euthanasia of animals by animal shelters.

2.7 Million Non-Suffering Dogs and Cats Euthanized Yearly in US Alone — ASPCA

According to the ASPCA, only 35% of pets are adopted from shelters, with an almost equal number euthanized, and 26% returned to owners. This represents 2.7 million dogs and cats yearly—in the USA alone. These are “non-suffering” animals, defined as animals disposed of due to overcrowding, lack of resources or expediency — not pets euthanized due to terminal illness and painful suffering. Canada, Taiwan (where Zicheng lived) and most other countries also “dispose” of unwanted pets by the millions.

 

2.7 million dogs and cats in the US alone are euthanized each year, most due to pressures of crowding.
2.7 million dogs and cats in the US alone are euthanized each year, most due to pressures of crowding.

 

Elisa Allen, Associate Director of PETA told MailOnline: ‘The reality is that there are simply not enough homes to go around for the millions of unwanted animals who are euthanized every year.”

Is Animal Shelter Euthanasia Due to Crowding Humane?

Millions of strays are euthanized each year according to PETA. In the opinion of the writers/editors at Buddha Weekly these are not “humane” killings — they are executions of unwanted or inconvenient animals.

Humane pet euthanasia can only be defined in the same way as it is human euthanasia. That is, it’s only humane where there is unbearable suffering, pain and diagnosis of impending death. Injecting pets with the same drugs we use for human executions of criminals (which is a different issue), begs the comparison. If the execution is one of convenience — to persevere resources, reduce over crowding, or minimize work load — then it is the complete opposite of a humane killing. It is nothing more than a killing of convenience, no better than the brutal people who abandon pets to shelters and throw puppies and kittens in dumpsters after their family tires of a pet.

But this is the, admittedly, strong opinion of the writers at Buddha Weekly. What do the Buddhist Teachers say?

 

Lama Zopa Rinpoche giving blessings of a dog at teachings.
Lama Zopa Rinpoche giving blessings of a dog at teachings.

 

Lama Zopa Rinpoche: Killing with a motivation that is “totally pure” becomes a virtue.

"What the Buddhist Teachers Say" is a long-running feature series. We pick a topic, then seek the opinions/ quote/ guidance of at least five teachers.

In the October, 2004 issue of Mandala magazine, a wonderful veterinary nurse, Leah Richards — probably struggling with the very issues that tore at Vetranarian Jian Zhicheng — asked the most Venerable Lama Zopa Rinpoche if her professional acts of “putting to sleep” suffering animals was negative karma. She was concerned, as are all Buddhists, with the lay vow “to abstain from killing.” Her struggle is a magnified one, the same issue a pet caregiver might face for an aging dog with cancer who is suffering unbearably. Only, for Nurse Leah Richards, she dealt with it regularly. The difference with Vet Zicheng is motivation. Leah Richards only dealt with euthanasia of pets suffering terminally.

From Mandala Magazine: ” Rinpoche told Leah that bodhisattvas have incredibly powerful bodhichitta and strong compassion deeply ingrained in their hearts. With such, they are willing to be born in the hell realms for the sake of another sentient being – that is, to sacrifice themselves in that way for another being.

“Therefore, when one kills with a true bodhichitta intention, with a heart filled with Dharma wisdom and compassion, the act actually becomes one in which it is “beneficial to kill.”

 

Vetranarian Jian Zhicheng (Chien Chih-cheng 簡稚澄) compelled by her animal shelter employer to euthanize over 700 stray dogs, killed herself with the same drugs to protest this policy of "easy" euthanasia.
Vetranarian Jian Zhicheng (Chien Chih-cheng 簡稚澄) compelled by her animal shelter employer to euthanize over 700 stray dogs, killed herself with the same drugs to protest this policy of “easy” euthanasia.

 

“This pure motivation behind the altruistic decision to end another sentient being’s suffering – putting them out of their misery by ending their present life while knowing absolutely that one could at that very moment be creating the karmic causes for one to be born in the hell realm – makes such a killing beneficial.” [1]

Although Rinpoche did not mention euthanasia of animals by shelters due to overcrowding, his words clearly would not define this as a positive motivation or virtue. Therefore, the killing would be a non-virtuous act, loaded with negative karma.

Elizabeth Mattis Namgyel: “The question itself requires us to be very big and courageous”

Author Elizabeth Namgyel, Retreat Master at Longchen Jigme Samten Ling, also takes the view that there is no “Buddhist rote answer” and that it comes down to motivation. She wrote on her blog: “I think the dharma goes much deeper than simply giving us “rote” answers. It is not that Buddhism “allows” or “doesn’t allow” anything. I don’t think it dictates what we “should” do but rather asks us to deeply examine cause and effect. And when our motivation is kind and loving, these choices are not so black and white. So I think no matter the circumstances there are consequences either way. You would have to be callous to not feel the consequences of putting down a being you love. And yet it can seem cruel to let them suffer unnecessarily at times. So the question itself requires us to be very big and courageous.”

Elizabeth is likely a Buddhist teacher has sympathy for a pet companion struggling with ending a life due to extreme end-of-life suffering, but, likely, not much support for an animal shelter euthanizing thousands to make space.

 

At least 1/3 of animals turned in to shelters will end up Euthanized due to overcrowding.
At least 1/3 of animals turned in to shelters will end up Euthanized due to overcrowding.

 

Teacher Consensus: No to Euthanasia — Except out of compassion

What seems to be unanimous amongst teachers — at least according to my findings after three weeks of extensive research — is that killing and Euthanasia is a big NO. However, many notable teachers point out that it’s not a “rote” teaching and that motivation and compassion must be considered. Many teachers support their student’s decisions to euthanize when the animal is in excruciating pain and cannot survive. But NO teacher, it seems, would endorse or support the killing of convenience as practiced by animal shelters. I did not find a single Buddhist endorsement of Euthanasia by animal shelters for any reasons other than end-of-life suffering.

Veterinarians Struggle: “Turns out many Buddhist won’t euthanize their pets”

Many Buddhists live by the Buddha’s specific prohibition not to kill. Period. This can be an issue in the case of extreme suffering. Veterinarian Patty Khuly struggled with the Buddhist idea of non killing for any reason. In her blog, she wrote about one Buddahist patient:

” I’ve got this patient whose cancer has not yet been named by the pathologist (we’re awaiting biopsy results), but it’s probably some nasty business given her symptoms. Which is why I tiptoed into the subject of euthanasia last week with her owners. To no avail. Turns out many Buddhists won’t euthanize their pets.

 

High volume euthanasia in animal shelters, as high as 69% in many shelters, is a routine daily event, often carried out without compassion.
High volume euthanasia in animal shelters, as high as 69% in many shelters, is a routine daily event, often carried out without compassion.

 

Though I know all about the “no killing” thing with Buddhists, this was news to me. After all, I’d euthanized pets from at least five Buddhist families. I guess this provision is not so uniformly considered in the same light by all Buddhists.”

How much worse must it be for a noble-hearted Veterinarian, like Jian Zhicheng, who went to school to learn how to save precious lives, only to be compelled to terminate the lives of hundreds of dogs and cats in the name of fiscal responsibility at an animal shelter. They struggle most, as Jian Zhicheng herself said, because so few people come forward to adopt these pets, condemned to death row, in favor of a puppy from a puppy mill.

Teachers Agree: Euthanasia with the wrong motivation is negative

From the Buddha, down through all lineages of teachers and teachings, Buddhists are universal in the prohibition not to kill. Euthanasia — whether it be of a beloved pet, or a beloved family member — is still divisive, with some teachers still endorsing “no killing” for any reason, and others, like Zopa Rinpoche, taking into account the motivation to reduce suffering.

However, no teacher, anywhere, has endorsed the euthanasia of animals for any reason other than to end extreme suffering for a terminally ill life. It is likely that Buddhists everywhere would tend to agree, obviously with the normal exceptions expected in a diverse society.

There can be, in Buddhist thinking, no justification for euthanasia of dogs and cats by animal shelters for the purposes of reducing over-crowding

NOTES

[1] Mandala Magazine “Euthanasia with a good heart

[2] Elizabeth Mattis Namgyel: Elizabeth has an academic backround in both Anthropology and Buddhist Studies, but her learning is also grounded in practice. After many years of solitary retreat, Rinpoche appointed Elizabeth as Retreat Master at Longchen Jigme Samten Ling, Mangala Shri Bhuti’s retreat center in southern Colorado. Elizabeth is the author ofThe Power of an Open Question: The Buddha’s Path to Freedom and is currently writing her next book, tentatively titled, “The Logic of Faith”, about faith and the Middle Way teachings. She has edited Dzigar Kongtrul Rinpoche’s two books, “It’s Up to You” and “Light Comes Through” and teaches the Buddhadharma in the United States and Europe. She is an avid rock climber and enjoys horseback riding, long walks and the contemplative life of Crestone, Colorado.

 

3 Responses to Veterinarian’s Suicide with Animal Euthanasia Drugs a Protest Against Animal “Mercy” Killings: What Do Buddhist Teachers Say About Animal Euthanasia?

  1. We have had to euthanise our pets due to their suffering of old age and cancer. Being Buddhist’s we made sure that our pets were helped in any way possible. We asked the vet to come to our home where they were familiar with their surroundings and said Mantra’s during the process. An Altar was created for them and they were placed in front of it and prayers were said for three days, morning and night. After this, they were cremated at our place and a gathering of students were present, doing Green Tara practise. The ashes were then placed under a new tree on our property. The dogs under a dogwood tree and our beloved old cat under a magnolia. There were definitely signs of approval for what took place. an example being our old cat, when the cremation was to take place it was bucketing down raining but as we decided to go ahead it stopped raining and a very, very bright rainbow appeared over the property. The cat had been cuddled by Zasep Rinpoche (our Guru) and the cat was always present at our gatherings. The family pets were also much loved by the students and i believe this certainly would have helped them. We then bought rescues who had suffered to become new family members. Compassion should be for all sentient beings.
    Kind Regards,
    Diederik.

    • That’s a wonderful story of compassionate euthanasia, and my respect to you for your compassion and courage. So wonderful Rinpoche was there. It’s wonderful you’ve adopted strays. I recently found a stray, but resisted turning him in to the shelter. Because we have many animals, it was hard to care for another, so I called the humane society and said, “If I bring him in and his owner doesn’t show up, or he’s not adopted, can you call me and not euthanize? I’d take the dog in if his owner doesn’t not appear.” The humane society said ‘No, we can’t do that. We follow our rules and guidelines.” Instead we ended up advertising everywhere. We refused to turn him in.
      Over 55 years or so we’ve had many beloved companions. My sixteen year old Dalmatian (which is VERY old for a DAL), who had cancer and excruciating pain, wagged her tail and licked everyone when it was happening. It was the right thing for her. She knew, we feel certain, and I think it was harder on the family than for her. Other times, over the years, we’ve managed by increasing the pain dosage. As medicine and veterinary care get better and better, the problem is end-of-life can be excruciating. This will never be a black/white issue. The main factor should always be compassion. Metta, Derek

  2. It is perplexing. Seeing family members on both sides suffer the ravages of dementia & Alzheimer’s. I have looked after many. Most recently keeping my Mom in her home another 4 years more then a psychiatrist thought I could or should. Having no children, no family that would care for me, spending as much as a decade in lock up in overcrowded hospitals without visitors, and imagining for years doing no spiritual practicing … I cannot see the annual tens of thousands of dollars spent on my care and mind altering drugs when one may have paranoia, rages or violent tendencies. What a horrible path to live.

    I do not understand why spending time receiving this unnecessary care is good path compared to human euthanasia when I start to become ill. I was told by a Buddhist monk, ‘no drugs and no ending your life’. That seems to be about receiving as my path, should it happen. I struggle with this and have plans made to quietly end life and stay out of the system when the time comes.

    Bi polar, cancer, AIDS, dementia and Alzheimer’s have taught me and my family to see a different ending for us than our parents and their siblings. I Imagine a time when I am forever woken up, fed, forced to be entertained even when I want to alone … in overcrowded conditions from 8 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. Until you are allowed to be alone in your room. If you are lucky not to have to share. No visitors or family. It sounds like a Hell Realm. I can’t imagine going through it. Assisted suicide would be humane. I understand it may be against the dharma advice given. But how am I to accept this possibility?

Leave a reply

Are you a Sentient Being? *

Copyright Buddha Weekly 2007-2017. All Rights Reserved. Please feel free to excerpt stories with full credit and a link to Budddha Weekly. Please do not use more than an excerpt. Subject to terms of use and privacy statement. All information on this site, including but not limited to, text, graphics, images and other material contained on this website are for informational purposes only. The purpose of this website is to promote  understanding and knowledge. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, including medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.

Buddha Weekly does not recommend or endorse any information that may be mentioned on this website. Reliance on any information appearing on this website is solely at your own risk.

Send this to a friend