Video Advice from the Buddhist Teachers on Bereavement: Advice for Someone Dealing with the Loss of a Loved One.
Meditation Techniques for People With Unsettled Monkey Minds
The Emptiness of Prayer—Who Do We Pray To? “You and the Buddha are not separate realities.” — Thich Nhat Hanh
Part 2 Interview: Alejandro Anastasio, Martial Arts and Dharma Teacher, Sees a Special Relationship Between Martial Arts and Buddhism: Dharma in Action
Heart Sutra: Why it’s My Favorite Sutra
Advice from the Teachers: How do we purify negative karma? Do you have advice for people confused by karma?
One Hand Speaks: Dharma Teacher AlejAndro Anastasio Speaks with Buddha Weekly About His Life as an Authorized Vajrayana Teacher, Inspirational Speaker, Martial Artist and One-Handed Superhero
Random Acts of Kindness Creates Good Karma. Mindful Acts of Kindness Refines Practice.
What’s Your Karmic Net Worth? Avoid Compound Negative Karmic Interest with Vajrasattva Mantra and Four Opponent Powers.
What the Teachers Say About Doggie Dharma: Did Buddha Teach That Dogs and Cats Have Buddha Nature? How Can You Help Your Companion Meet the Dharma in Daily Life? What to Do About Euthanasia?
May all beings have happiness and its causes! Wishing you a healthy and peaceful Holiday and New Year from Buddha Weekly.
May all beings have happiness and its causes! Seasons Greetings from Buddha Weekly. May you have peace in the New Year!
Lama Tsongkhapa: A Short, Powerful Practice Helps Bring Compassion, Wisdom, Good Fortune, and Healing
December 23 is Lama Tsongkhapa Day — Ganden Ngamchoe, anniversary of Lama Tsongkhapa’s parinirvana!
Swift Healing with White Tara: the Rapid Path to Long Life, Merit, Wisdom, and Health
The Lotus Born Guru Rinpoche: Master Padma’s Ten Key Points, Ten Foundations, Ten Faults, Ten Superficialities
What the Teachers Say About Doggie Dharma: Did Buddha Teach That Dogs and Cats Have Buddha Nature? How Can You Help Your Companion Meet the Dharma in Daily Life? What to Do About Euthanasia?

What the Teachers Say About Doggie Dharma: Did Buddha Teach That Dogs and Cats Have Buddha Nature? How Can You Help Your Companion Meet the Dharma in Daily Life? What to Do About Euthanasia?

"What the Buddhist Teachers Say" is a long-running feature series. We pick a topic, then seek the opinions/ quote/ guidance of at least five teachers.

I saw a sparkling moment of real Doggie Dharma last weekend. At a Medicine Buddha retreat, a nice couple brought along their beloved 15 month-old pup. My kind teacher, Zasep Tulku Rinpoche, smiled as they lifted the pup for a blessing after the teachings. I had brought along my bell and vajra for blessing. Others, their mala. I didn’t even think of bringing my doggie companion!

After the final blessings, Rinpoche played with this cute little dog on the floor and hugging him in his arms. The smiles on both of their faces conveyed real-life Dharma in practice. 

 

Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche blessed this dog at the end of a Medicine Buddha Retreat in Owen Sound in April 2016. After the event he played with the fifteen-month old pup. Zasep Rinpoche teaches, "We must not hurt other people and animals."
Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche blessed this dog at the end of a Medicine Buddha Retreat in Owen Sound in April 2016. After the event he played with the fifteen-month old pup. Zasep Rinpoche teaches, “We must not hurt other people and animals.” [6]

From a Buddhist point of view, dogs, cats, companion animals — in fact all animals and sentient life — are equally precious. According to Buddha Dharma, all sentient beings also have Buddha Nature — the potential to eventually become enlightened.

Theodore Tsaousidis, a teacher with Medicine Buddha Toronto, said, “If we accept that all beings have Buddha nature, then the greatest goal in life is to see our true nature and then help others to also realize their true nature.” [5]

 

Buddha Blesses an Elephant
Buddha blesses an elephant. Buddha taught that all animals have Buddha Nature.

 

Lama Zopa Rinpoche: “The Teaching to 500 Swans”

Lama Zopa Rinpoche, in a teaching on “animals in everyday life” wrote: “There is a story when Buddha gave teachings to 500 swans in the field and the next life they were born as human beings, became monks, and they all became Arya beings, able to achieve the cessation of suffering and the true path. So the result is unbelievable, just by hearing Dharma words.” This teaching illustrates that all animals have Buddha Nature. The swans, in just one life cycle, became humans, monks, and ultimately Aryas.

 

Lama Zopa Rinpoche blesses horses at a rescue farm.
Lama Zopa Rinpoche blesses horses at a rescue farm.

 

Lama Zopa Rinpoche continued: “Vasubandhu was reciting the Abhidharmakosha and a pigeon on the roof heard this everyday. One day the pigeon died and Vasubandhu checked to see where he was born. It was in a family who lived down below in the valley. He went down and saw the child and asked if he could have him and the family gave him to Vasubandhu. The child became a monk named Lobpön Loden and became an expert on the text that he had heard when he was a pigeon. He wrote four commentaries on that text. Therefore, it’s extremely important to recite lam-rim prayers and mantras — at least the mantras — to animals.”

 

Buddha blesses an elephant. Buddha taught that all animals have Buddha Nature.
Buddha blesses the animals. Buddha taught that all animals have Buddha Nature.

 

Bring our animal companions into our meditations?

Most Buddhists are familiar with these stories. Yet, in real life, do we really treat our animal companions as fellow journeyers on the path to Enlightenment? If we did, we’d bring our pets meditation rooms and retreats (with Teacher’s permission, of course!)— as the nice couple did during last weekend’s Medicine Buddha retreat. We’d acknowledge our companions are subject to Karma, just like us. This means that, as their friends, we need to be mindful of their actions, as much as our own, because they, too, have Buddha Nature. They, like the swans, can become Aryas (Enlightened Beings).

 

Dogs in Thailand can find sanctuary in any Buddhist Temple. Nearly every temple has resident stray dogs, fed and cared for by monks despite the fact the monks have to beg for their own food.
Dogs in Thailand can find sanctuary in any Buddhist Temple. Nearly every temple has resident stray dogs, fed and cared for by monks despite the fact the monks have to beg for their own food.

 

Theodore Tsaousidis explained you have to take responsibility. “If you refuse to be honest about every single choice you make in your 24 hour day, then Buddhism, for you, is just another distraction.” When we take on responsibility for animal companions, we also take on choices that affect them, their development, and their future lives.

Lobsang Dhargey: “recite mantra and pray for animals”

Lobsang Dhargey, resident teacher at the Tibetan Buddhist Centre in Redding advises “recite mantras and pray for the animals.” Not when they are dying, but throughout their lives. At the Centre in Redding, they perform animal blessing ceremonies. “We believe animals are like humans with emotions. Animals can be sad, afraid, worried, wish to be happy…” At the event in 2014, nearly 100 residents brought dogs, cats, horses, turtles, sheep and goats to be blessed. [3]

 

At the Centre in Redding, they perform animal blessing ceremonies. At the event in 2014, nearly 100 residents brought dogs, cats, horses, turtles, sheep and goats to be blessed.
At the Tibetan Buddhist Centre in Redding, they perform animal blessing ceremonies. At the event in 2014, nearly 100 residents brought dogs, cats, horses, turtles, sheep and goats to be blessed.

 

The concept of the blessing is to “make this potential [to be happy] better by blessing the animals… visualize their lives being better.” As they chant mantras and prayers, they plant “a kind of seed that grows in the minds of animals to give them good health and a better life.”

Lama Zopa Rinpoche: practices you can do for animals

Medicine Buddha is well known as a practice for animals. It is taught that Medicine Buddha’s mantra when spoken in a dying animal’s ear, will help release it from lower rebirth, ensuring birth as a human. [Buddha Weekly story on Medicine Buddha here>>]

Kyabje Lama Zopa Rinpoche also advises these mantras or practices as beneficial for animals, throughout their lives to help bless their mindstreams:

  • Medicine Buddha: Om Bekhandze Bekhandze Maha Bekhandze Bekhandze Randza Samundgate Soha
  • Green Tara: Om Tare Tuttare Ture Soha
  • Avalokiteshvara (Chenrezig or Guanyin): Om Mani Padme Hum
  • Milarepa: Om Ah Guru Hasa Vajra Sarva Siddhi Hum

 

Lama Zopa Rinpoche giving blessings of a dog at teachings.
Lama Zopa Rinpoche giving blessings of a dog at teachings.

 

Throughout their every day lives, it is best to consider, or include, your animal companion in your practices. He advises. “Take them around holy objects — circumambulate… Chant mantras…” Recite prayers in their ears to “plant the seed of all the realizations of the path to enlightenment.”

He writes in his popular advice web page: “this makes a huge difference. It has inconceivable result, unbelievable result. That makes them have a good rebirth in the next life, to be born as a human being and meet the Dharma.” He also recommends blessing their food.

Lama Zopa’s advice for sick animals

For sick animals you can recite Medicine Buddha healing mantras over medicine or water and then blow on the liquid before giving to an animal. In the case of a deceased companion, the same mantras are beneficial, chanted at least 21 times, preferably 108, blowing water and visualizing the deity or the deity’s blessing light being absorbed. Then pour the water on the deceased.

For a dying animal, Lama Zopa Rinpoche recommended saying the entire Medicine Buddha sadhana.[5]

Venerable Thubton Chodron: Daily Doggie Dharma — suggestions for daily life

The much respected and loved teacher Venerable Thubten Chodron advised a student named Bob to spend time putting “good karmic imprints on his mindstream…It will establish a connection between him [his dog] and the Three Jewels, so that he will meet the teachings and have an affinity for them in future lives.” [1]

 

A monk, while in practice, shares with a puppy.
A monk, while in practice, shares with a puppy.

 

Venerable Chodron also advised: “So read Dharma books or short texts or prayers out loud to him, e.g. the Heart Sutra, The Three Principle Aspects of the Path, The Foundation of All Good Qualities, etc. Say lots of mantra so he hears it.” She was speaking to a student who’s pet was dying, but the advice is best applied much earlier, long before sickness and end of life issues.

Daily Meditation: include an animal companion

Many Buddhists encourage their pets to settle down in a room where they meditate or perform daily sadhanas. Cats, in particular, seem drawn to practice, often snuggling right in the lap of the meditator. Of course, highly precise, advanced tantric practices might not be the best for pets, but for simpler practices — quiet breathing practice, mantra practice or sutra reading — the company is very beneficial.

Personally, I’ve found my dog, cats and horses all respond noticeably to mantras, and I chant them whenever I am with them. When I’m feeding the horses, I’m inevitably chanting the Medicine Buddha mantra, remembering His vow to heal and save all beings, and in particular his vow to help all beings and animals. The teachings say that his mantra, when chanted to animals, sets them on the path to higher birth.

 

All over Asia, dogs know they can come to compassionate monks for food and care when no one else cares.
All over Asia, dogs know they can come to compassionate monks for food and care when no one else cares.

 

Doggie Dharma at end of your companion’s life

Buddha is often portrayed in stories and illustrations with animals.
Buddha is often portrayed in stories and illustrations with animals.

We usually only start thinking of Doggie Dharma when a beloved pet is about to pass away, or has already died. Buddhist forums fill up with discussions on the Buddhist view on Euthanasia, and rebirth and other ethical hot buttons, almost always started by a struggling Buddhist caregiver facing the end-of-life of a beloved companion.

As Buddhists, we often take solace in the doctrine of rebirth at such times. Buddha was clear on this. Animals, like humans, take actions and are subject to karma and rebirth. Therefore, our actions as their caregivers also have karmic implications — including that hot potato euthanasia. The time to think about Dharma and a beloved pet’s Karmic well-being is from the first day you adopt — not just when they are sick or dying.

For many animal companion lovers, this is a relief, particularly as their friends typically have shorter lifespans. The idea that their beloved companion will be reborn is a major consolation.

Venerable Thubten Semkye: “pouring the light of their loving compassion…”

In consoling a fellow animal caregiver, Venerable Semkye wrote, “Even though Achala lived his entire life surrounded by the Dharma in a very conducive environment, his ability to practice was non-existent due to his karma of being born as a cat… Prayers, mantra recitations and visualizing the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas pouring the light of their loving compassion and wisdom on him were a very powerful practice.” [1]

Venerable Semkye explained, “Animals are very sensitive to our energies and mind states. So, keeping our hearts soft and open was crucial. We wanted him to feel our love and care, not worry or disturbances.”

 

Dogs are permanent residents in Thai Buddhist temples, where euthanasia is unheard of. Often, old or sick dogs are dropped off at temples because Thai's know that monks will care for them.
Dogs are permanent residents in Thai Buddhist temples, where euthanasia is unheard of. Often, old or sick dogs are dropped off at temples because Thai’s know that monks will care for them.

 

If a beloved pet is sick — just as we might for our human family members — make a doctor’s appointment, but also meditate on the Three Jewels, perhaps chant mantras or sutras. We might chant the mantras over our pet’s water, or their medicine prescribed by the vet, then blow on them, just as we would for our children.

Caregiver Karma — we can take on heavy karma

We, as caregivers, inevitably take on the potential for negative karma from the moment we adopt. There’s positive karma, of course, especially if we rescue an animal from the pound or the streets, or take on an elderly or infirmed pet when no one else will. As we care for our loved one, that’s all positive, of course.

 

Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche takes a moment to play with a puppy brought to a Medicine Buddha retreat for blessing.
Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche, spiritual head of Gaden for the West and Gaden Choling Toronto, takes a moment to play with a puppy brought to a Medicine Buddha retreat for blessing. The retreat was in Owen Sound, hosted by Mindfulness of Grey Bruce and Theodore Tsaousidis.

 

Where does the negative karma arise? If we believe meat derives from killing, the precepts come into play, notably the prohibition from taking life when we buy dog or cat food (See “The Precepts”, below). But, just as with humans, the negative karma may not apply if the killing is not specifically for our benefit. In one sense, as caregiver, we are preventing our companions from killing. If not fed, their natural needs as predators (in the case of cats or dogs) would arise, bringing on negative karmic implications on their mind streams.

As the more “responsible” partner in the relationship, we make decisions for our companions, which restrict their free will. Other negative karmic implications can occur if we spoil our companions; they may become unmanageable or hostile in society. And so on. It’s no different with children. These are all potentially negative karma for us.

Theodore Tsaousidis: “You have a choice as a human not to cause harm.”

Most Buddhists, as compassionate people, tend to love animals. Yet, even if we don’t have that affinity or desire to care take animals, our behavior in daily life still has to reflect our Buddhist compassion and our acceptance of karmic consequences.

 

Buddha-Weekly-Theodore Tsausidis and Zasep Tulku Rinpoche-Buddhism
Theodore Tsaousidis (right) was asked to teach by the most Venerable Zasep Tulku Rinpoche (left).

 

Theodore Tsaousidis of Medicine Buddha Toronto said, “If we look at cosmology and mythology in Buddhism, particularly the Jataka Tales, we see beings manifest in various forms: such as spirits, animals, gods and humans. Depending on the ripening of one’s karma, you may be reborn in any of the six realms. This can be determined based on the choices we make today. You have a choice as a human not to cause harm to any being. This is the best opportunity to end the cycle of death and rebirth.”

Dog Temples: Thais often take dogs to their temple so they can die in peace

Inevitably, in most countries, when our companion is suffering terribly at the end of life, and the veterinarian gives no hope, euthanasia rises as an issue.

In Thailand, where the population is mostly Buddhist, euthanasia is unthinakable. For this reason, thousands of dogs are taken to temples to die in peace under the care of monks. They know monks consider life precious and will share food— this despite the fact these monks depend on alms themselves to live.

 

Cows feel emotions, according to the majority of scientists. A glance at this happy cow reinforces this fact.
All animals have Buddha Nature. According to a Declaration by prominent scientists, animals feel emotions and are sentient in the same way as humans. See story on this declaration on Buddha Weekly>>

 

On one hand the Thais provide a good example of Buddhist Metta (kindness). They won’t kill stray or aging dogs. When these strays wander into temples where monks have little themselves, they find homes and food. On the other hand, this policy has led to hundreds of thousands of stray and starving dogs on the street. Yet, even the poorest of Thais try to feed these strays. According to Eric Beauchemin, “even poor people are trying to help these animals. Some of them go around on bicycles and feed up to a 100 dogs a day!”[2]

Euthanasia: unable to cope with our companion’s pain

In Buddhism, taking a life is prohibited — any life, not just human. This makes euthanasia a big issue with Buddhist pet caregivers. Some Buddhists, just like the Thai Buddhists, would let their pet suffer to their last breath, no matter how severe the pain, due to teachings along the lines of “to cut short their suffering prevents them from extinguishing their karma leading to poor rebirth.”

Others Buddhists, unable to cope with the pain their animal companion is enduring, might consider euthanasia — acknowledging, as they do so, that they are taking on the negative karma of taking a life.

Lama Zopa Rinpoche on euthanasia: “Bodhisattvas… sacrifice themselves…for another being.”

In answering a question from a veterinary nurse who was concerned about euthanasia in her professional life, Lama Zopa gave balanced advice. He reiterated that we are prohibited from killing, but qualified his answer in a very kind way:

“This pure motivation behind the altruistic decision to end another sentient being’s suffering – putting them out of their misery by ending their present life while knowing absolutely that one could at that very moment be creating the karmic causes for one to be born in the hell realm – makes such a killing beneficial.” [4]

 

Buddha with monkey and elephant

 

The article explained: “Rinpoche told Leah that bodhisattvas have incredibly powerful bodhichitta and strong compassion deeply ingrained in their hearts. With such, they are willing to be born in the hell realms for the sake of another sentient being – that is, to sacrifice themselves in that way for another being.” In essence, yes, we do take on negative karma by the act of compassionate euthanasia, but it still can be beneficial to make that personal sacrifice to ease the excruciated suffering of your animal companions.”

One of my personal friends had this experience. She explained that she took on the negative karma from euthanizing her companion gladly — just to stop the suffering of their pet.

Dharma “all beings, all of whom have been our mothers”

It is inarguable that Buddha taught that animals are considered sentient beings. Dharma also clearly teaches that humans can be reborn as animals in future lives, just as animals can be reborn as humans. The Precepts also prohibit taking life, including animals.

Many Mahayana meditations, sadhanas and prayers use language such as “all beings, all of whom have been our mothers…” — a constant reminder that every being, even the insect we step on by accident, is potentially our family. Ultimately, Mahayana Buddhists accept that humans and animals are interconnected as a single family.

 

Buddha with the birds

 

All this to say, your doggie, kitty, hamster, budgie and extended animal companions all have both Buddha Nature and karma. In what ways does this change our relationship to our beloved companions?

The Precepts prohibit taking of life — not just human life

While most religions prohibit the taking of human life, Buddhism goes much further. One of the most important precepts taught by Shakyamuni prohibited the taking of any life. There is a negative karmic implication in any deliberate killing — much less so in the case of an accidental killing. (In other words, if you accidentally step on an ant, this is not negative karma, but if you deliberately step on the ant, or set an ant trap, this is heavy negative karma. Needless to say, insect and rodent control must be highly skillful to avoid negative karma for a serious Buddhist — rodent proof containers and cleanliness replace traps and poison.)

Lama Zopa Rinpoche explained “that the vow of non-killing refers to abstaining from killing that is associated with and backed by ignorance and negative attachment. It is that kind of killing that creates negative karma. Only killing with a motivation that is “totally pure” becomes a virtue.” [4]

Eating animals

The prohibition on all killing one reason some Buddhists are vegetarian — although there is no precept prohibiting meat specifically. You are prohibited from killing for meat, but if you were given meat, in theory, you could eat it. However, if your demand for meat contributes to the slaughter of animals, it carries negative karma. A monk, for example, could accept donated meat, but the animal must not have been slaughtered specifically for the monk. Because of this precept, some strict Buddhist monks used to carry fly swishes to carefully whisk away insects without killing them.

This notion is not fanciful. In the Golden Light Sutra, Shakyamuni, in a past life as Prince Sattva, fed himself to a tigress and her babies so that they would not starve.

For less traditional Buddhists, secular Buddhists or “Buddhists without beliefs” rebirth is not necessarily accepted as fact — although karma certainly is — making Doggie Dharma a more straight-forward discussion. But, as it is certain that rebirth was taught by Buddha, most Buddhists accept the wider implications of animal Buddha Nature and the cycle of lower/higher rebirth.

 

NOTES

[1] “Is euthanizing pets advisable” by Venerable Thubten Chodron Jan 9, 2011

[2] “A Buddhist lesson in pet care” by Eric Becuchemin, Radio Netherlands, Feb 2006, The Buddhist Channel.

[3] “Buddhists offer blessing of animals: chanting, prayers greet pets for good health, better future” by Catherine Samose, Special to The Redding Pilot.

[4] “Euthanasia with a good heart” Lama Zopa Rinpoche, fpmt website.

[5] “Advice on Benefiting animals” Lama Zopa Rinpoche

[6] In response to Buddha Weekly request, answered on April 28, 2016. Theodore Tsaousidis is a teacher authorized by Zasep Tulku Rinpoche, who teaches with Medicine Buddha Toronto and Mindfulness Centre of Grey Bruce

[7] “Student Guidelines”, Zasep Tulku Rinpoche

Leave a reply

Are you a Sentient Being? *

Copyright Buddha Weekly 2007-2016. All Rights Reserved. Please feel free to excerpt stories with full credit and a link to Budddha Weekly. Please do not use more than an excerpt. Subject to terms of use and privacy statement.